This film is a PG, was released on August 17th 2018 and this review will contain NO SPOILERS
Introduction
The live action remakes by Disney in the 2010s don't exactly have a smooth track record. Yes there are some bright spots like 2016's The Jungle Book or 2015's Cinderella, but more often that not, they end up being shallow and simply living in the shadow of their animated version. However, one way they try to avoid this is by changing things around so they can stand on their own and not be a basic retreading, whether it be going from a different view or adding new elements. This is where 2018's Christopher Robin comes in.
I love Winnie the Pooh. It was
honestly one of the biggest chunks of my childhood. I love the original
books but also the Disney versions. However, last year there was a film called Goodbye Christopher Robin which explored the life of author A.A Milne and the misfortunes of his titular son. I thought it was really interesting to see exactly how these characters came about. Who would've thought that Disney would then make a Winnie the Pooh movie less than a year later. This film has no relation to that but is seemingly a Winnie the Pooh tale with a twist.
Thoughts Going In
I wasn't going to go out of my way to see this, especially because I am still yet to see Ant-Man and the Wasp, but I knew that it'd at least be sweet or charming. Anything with Winnie the Pooh involved would always be likeable, and I'd always feel bad if I ever disliked anything with him. So, I didn't sense anything big on the horizon, but I did sense something nice.
The Story
Christopher Robin, played by Ewan McGregor, is now grown up, and in a position where his job is seemingly of a larger priority than his family, so much so that he cannot spend a weekend in the countryside, where he grew up, with them. Meanwhile, his old childhood friend, Winnie the Pooh, is having trouble finding his friends, so he pays Robin a visit and slowly we're is reintroduced to the whole gang, Tigger, Piglet, Rabbit and so on. In this time, Robin begins to understand what the most important thing in his life truly is.
What I Liked
Well, my favourite thing about this film was by far the animated characters. As I said, I grew up with them and it was really nice to see all of them with their new CGI appearance. The effects are beautiful and they look very much like stuffed animals with the detail of the fur and textures, yet they all have a character that is easily identifiable. That and the voice work is terrific, with what I believe is one of the original voices, Jim Cummings, playing the roles of Pooh and Tigger. He did it so wonderfully and they sound just as you'd imagine. I do have a few issues with these animals which I will get into later but regarding their look and portrayal, it is the best thing this film has to offer.
But, the true star here is Christopher Robin himself, and Ewan McGregor does a good job. To me he is a very talented actor because he can go from being a drug addict in Danny Boyle's Trainspotting to Obi Wan in the Star Wars prequel series, so he can cover a lot of demographics. But, he didn't ever have a crucial role in a film aimed at children, apart from Lumiere in Beauty and the Beast last year. Here, he is very charming and witty in this role. He has just the right amount of likeability and needed harshness to convey his character. I couldn't really imagine anyone else playing this part, at least in the way he did.
Also, the general feel of the film is sweet. The characters act in their iconic ways and the combination of them with Robin and the setting adds up to a very satisfying watch when comparing it to what has come before. There are many situations that revolve around the stupidity of Pooh along with heffalumps and woozies. Even though it may not have had me laughing away, it still raised a smile and brought internal amusement. The silly old bear is so charming that I feel it should be illegal to dislike him, or at least in this interpretation.
What I Didn't Like
Okay, I have some nitpicks which I feel I should address because they did bother me. My biggest issue is the science / logic behind the animals. Originally, the idea was that Christopher Robin was the only one who saw them as living, breathing creatures, whereas everyone else just saw stuffed toys. However, this film makes us believe that they are actually sentient. This is a big problem because it forgets what the classic stories are all about, the imagination of this one boy. I feel that if the way the animals worked in this world was the same as the originals, then the interplay between them and Christopher would've been more interesting, because we'd see how the toys are perhaps symbolic of the importance Christopher needs to find in his family, and the whole message about something coming from nothing would make sense equally because the toys may seem like nothing yet they're so much to him. Obviously that doesn't make perfect sense but with some development, it could be really powerful. But what we're left with is basically like Toy Story if the toys didn't freeze when Andy came to play.
Also, in terms of continuity, the film doesn't hold up. After the film Goodbye Christopher Robin, many elements in the storytelling are clearly made up. It shows Robin's father passing away when he was at a very young age, which isn't accurate, and it also glosses over the rough childhood he went through. But the biggest problem is, there is no reference to the books. Granted, this is fictional. And ignoring certain things for the purpose of storytelling is perfectly fine, but to me it makes the film less believable because we're meant to believe that the books were never a thing, and after I've been familiarized with how the books came to be, a grown up Christopher Robin living life in the way this film presents it just seems hard to get my head around, even if this is just fiction and we're pretending the books aren't real. It also serves as a missed opportunity for some interesting character moments where maybe the animals get recognized as they enter the city. Another thing regarding recognizing the animals is that the film is walking a tightrope regarding what generation of these characters it is trying to represent. Clearly it is reflective of the Disney interpretation with Pooh having his iconic red shirt along with the design of Eeyore, but characters like Tigger and Piglet seem straight out of the original books. Obviously you can look past this, but I think it opens up some problems.
The last big issue was something that was very evident. This film is trying to compete with Paddington, another family film that centres around a small CGI bear. In theory, the 2 bears are quite similar. They both have an owner who lives in London, they both have an obsession with an orange spread that you put on your toast and they're both quite lovably dimwitted in the fact that they often misinterpret sarcasm and constantly end up messing things up. However, where Paddington succeeds is that it is very heartwarming, has funny slapstick and comedy that all the family will enjoy, and it is made by people who clearly understand everything the source material meant and stood for. Here, it only succeeds with one of those things, that being the heartwarming side. The slapstick and other comedy is there but will really only appeal to those below the age of 10 apart from the occasional chuckle, and the creators clearly don't understand the true spirit of the source, based off what I said earlier. In summary, this film doesn't tick all the boxes when compared to what it is clearly trying to compete with.
Conclusion
So, you can view this film from one of two perspectives. On the one hand, it is made by people who don't fully appreciate what they're basing it off along with not succeeding in all of what it sets out to do. However, the way I see it is as a sweet, charming film where people can see some iconic characters up on the big screen with some entertaining performances and terrific effects. Despite all the flaws I have, I don't mind this film and I can certainly visualize plenty of families having a good time and a laugh. I also think that even though it is not as good of a film, I would rather watch it than Goodbye Christopher Robin, simply because it is so much sweeter and suited for my taste. It may seem like I have a lot of issues but in actuality, when you look at it as a simple piece of fiction, it's a fine watch.
I'm going to give Christopher Robin an O