With a certain 4th entry into a franchise out now, I thought it'd be fun to rank all the films made by my favourite animation studio, Pixar. While I do love a good Aardman or even Dreamworks film, Pixar have been the long reigning champions of computer animation ever since they introduced the medium to cinema in the 90s. I have seen every single film they've put out and have varying opinions on a lot of them, but as they've got a nice even number of films as of right now, I'm going to give them a rank.
Just like Marvel, the worst that Pixar gets from me is a 5/10. I can't bring myself to hate or even dislike any of their films, even the weaker ones. I also need to make it clear that my opinion on films are constantly changing. Looking back at my MCU ranking today, I already disagree with it. So keep in mind that this is a rough ranking and not set in stone. I'm also not going to mention animation unless it's absolutely necessary because it goes without saying that Pixar's animation is astonishing. That said, let's get ranking!
I also feel like I should address that a lot of my mini-reviews here are going to feel repetitive because many of these films share good aspects, so excuse me if my vocabulary doesn't seem varied enough. Also, this is a difficult list because I adore so many of these films and it's hard to say which ones are better, I even feel bad putting some so low on the list. This only really applies from numbers 11-1, those are the ones I love the most.
20. Brave (2012)
Brave is the lowest on my list for two main reasons. One, the film is extremely forgettable and conventional based on what I can remember, making it an unenjoyable experience. Two, it doesn't feel like a Pixar film. Pixar are so unique and original that them putting their spin on a common narrative felt very uninteresting. I'm being vague because I honestly have trouble remembering this movie, it feels like a lower tier Disney movie from the 2000s if anything. It also beat Wreck-it Ralph for the best animated feature Oscar, which intensifies my distaste.
Rating: 5/10
19. Cars 2 (2011)
A worse film than Brave from a story standpoint but the reason why this is higher is because when I watch this film, I'm not bored. It's ridiculous and makes no sense and damages the reputation of the original Cars movie, but at least it's not dull and it does have a personality. It's fun to watch simply because it's so more exciting and memorable, even if the everything else is really weak. I'd still like to imagine this movie doesn't exist and you'll see why later.
Rating: 6/10
18. The Good Dinosaur (2015)
A film that I've liked less and less since its release. This is mostly because I haven't felt the
urge to revisit it at all. I liked it a lot when I first saw it and actually
felt a desperate need to defend it, but gradually I forgot more and more
about it to the point where I still acknowledge its existence but don't
really think about what it adds to anything. The animation is especially
groundbreaking and the story is generally sweet and heartfelt, but
aside from that, there's not an awful lot to grasp onto here. An unfortunate misfire considering that dinosaurs are the best, but not bad by any means.
Rating: 7/10
17. Finding Dory (2016)
Another film I've liked less and less which is a shame. You'll see my opinion on Finding Nemo later (and where it is ranked should show you why this is so low), but I really liked this film at first because it was exciting to see a follow up to a film I absolutely loved. That and it has a much appreciated heartfelt story too. However, when you realise just how inessential this film is, then you like it slightly less. That happened to me for sure and I just started to enjoy it less. It's not a terrible film, but it's low on the list because it didn't have much of a reason to exist in the first place.
Rating: 7/10
16. Monsters University (2013)
Thankfully, we have a movie that has grown on me since I first saw it. I wasn't too keen on this when I first saw it because I mostly didn't like the segment in the human world as it became a bit too serious and grim for my taste, lacking the charm of the first film. However, that scene isn't a problem to me anymore as I think it was severe case of the negativity bias. I like a lot about the rest of the film; the overall ride it offers has some fun moments, some really hilarious characters, and it's a nice enough way to see how Mike and Sulley became the duo we all know and love.
Rating: 8/10
15. Coco (2018)
Coco is undeniably a great movie. It has a wonderfully emotional story, some delightful songs, really well-handled themes of memory / death, and it is always fun to watch, even though I've only seen it twice. What bothers me about this one is that, like Brave, it doesn't feel like a Pixar movie. Once again, there isn't much originality here. We've seen this type of story before and even though it hasn't been told with this particular aesthetic, it seems familiar due to the 2014 film, The Book of Life. So, this is a great movie, but just one that doesn't scream Pixar to me, and that's why it's so low.
Rating: 8/10
14. The Incredibles (2004)
Uh oh, you may not agree with this. Ah well, this is my list so deal with it. I've always liked The Incredibles, and it is a fantastic movie in many ways. The action is exciting and entertaining, the characters and their powers are a lot of fun, and it has some mature themes which are very subtly implemented. So, it is great, but there are just a lot of other movies that I think are better. To be honest, I haven't seen this movie in many years, and subsequently I have become a huge fan of superhero movies, so revisiting it may raise it on my list, but from what I remember, all of the ones I'm about to cover are superior to me.
Rating: 8/10
13. Incredibles 2 (2018)
JUST TO CLARIFY, I am uncertain as to whether or not this beats the original. But I'm fairly certain it does. I like the idea of The Incredibles being a satirical and goofy take on superhero movies, and this movie delivers that aspect much better than the original. The first movie was quite serious with occasional fun moments, but here, it's so much funnier and the super-baby, Jack-Jack, had a much larger role which gave the film lots more to love. This also means that both sides of the story are equally as entertaining, unlike the first where the only fun parts were all the full on superhero moments. I really enjoyed this movie and despite the animation being a little too good, it's a fabulous watch. I've written a full review if you'd like to hear more.
Rating: 8/10
12. A Bug's Life (1998)
The least talked about of Pixar's Golden Age movies, and deservedly so. Looking back, it doesn't have an awful lot that is boundary pushing or memorable about it, but it's a colourful and fun watch for the most part. Some good characters and great use of size, so overall a satisfying enough flick. There's really no more to say than that, but sometimes a nice straight forward story works better than a complex one in my opinion.
Rating: 8/10
11. Toy Story (1995)
This may seem a little bit too low considering we wouldn't have had the 10 films coming up if this one didn't exist, but I think it fits snugly here. Toy Story is a really enjoyable, creative and fun film. It still holds up today as a great kids movie and one of the best animated films ever made. The characters and voice work are top notch, and the story has a lot of depth to it, and the scene where Buzz flies is one of my favourite scenes in all of cinema. It feels so wrong having it so low on the list, it's just there are so many films that are better to me, even if this was the one that paved the way for all of them.
Rating: 8/10
10. Monsters, Inc. (2001)
Really entertaining. Mike and Sulley are one of Pixar's best duos and their chemistry is so well realised and it makes the movie so good. That and the little girl, Boo, is absolutely adorable! This film is also a prime example of Pixar being original as the world established here is something so bizarre in the best way possible. It's still a great movie today and one I always like to revisit, even if a lot of its peers are considered better by me.
Rating: 8/10
9. Cars 3 (2017)
I really love this movie. This is what I wished Cars 2 was going to be like. Out of all Pixar sequels, aside from the Toy Story ones, this one justifies its existence best. The narrative feels naturally progressed as Lightning follows in the footsteps (or tyre-tracks) of his mentor, Doc, and is passing the torch to his younger companion, Cruz. Top this off with a great message about growing and moving on and some really exciting and entertaining racing scenes, which go from race tracks to a demolition derby to out in the country, Cars 3 redeems the Cars series and I am happy it exists so that Cars is no longer frowned upon deeply by most Pixar fans.
Rating: 8/10
8. Inside Out (2015)
Oddly enough, this was probably the Pixar film I had the most hype for. Prior to this being released, we had a whole year of no Pixar! I mean, we still got The Lego Movie that year, but that isn't the point. I was so worried we'd never see another Pixar film for ages. Then, this film was released. And my worries were all pushed aside. Inside Out is a return to form if I've ever seen one. Such a wonderful story that utilises every aspect of the premise, such a creative setting, such brilliant characters, such a lovely score, such phenomenally realised emotions. This is just a masterful film. The only issues are that it has a few plot holes and to me still doesn't feel entirely like Pixar, but it is something truly special.
Rating: 9/10
7. Wall-E (2008)
I've loved Wall-E for so long. Being such a memorable character as well as a very wondrous film. Now, I like it ever so slightly less than I used to, but that doesn't mean it's a worse movie at all. This is definitive proof that "show don't tell" can be efficient in cinema, especially animation. It's also amazing how the animation crew managed to get such easily observable emotion out of a robot who isn't that expressive. Wall-E only has two gigantic, binocular eyes, and yet you can easily detect how he feels from any frame of the film. That is the work of pure wonder, and in and of itself makes this a terrific film. The message is also really powerful, the score is really pleasant, and the love story between Wall-E and Eve is so sweet. I just love it. Also, like Toy Story, Wall-E houses one of my favourite scenes in cinema. I'm sure you know the one, but if you don't, it's define dancing.
Rating: 9/10
6. Toy Story 2 (1999)
What a brilliant sequel! Toy Story 2 succeeds in all the ways any sequel should. Introduce new themes, expand on original themes, expand the world, deepen the characters, and deliver more of the humour and charm from the original. This film masterfully fills that criteria, and it adds up to a film that outdoes the original by quite a margin.
Rating: 9/10
5. Ratatouille (2007)
Ratatouille is another film I've grown to love as I've got older. Originally, this was quite low on my list. However, as an older person, you come to appreciate just how clever this film is. It has such a wonderfully bonkers premise, but the execution is fabulous in every way. It's very much a film that children can enjoy by the sight of things such as a pancake being flung out of a window, but you only come to appreciate all the nuances of the writing and the story itself as you grow up. Ratatouille also has the most clever title of any Pixar film, just everything about it is really smart. It is so entertaining and I never realised just how much I loved it and love to rewatch it.
Rating: 9/10
4. Up (2009)
Oh, I'm getting teary eyes just thinking about this. Up is another beautiful film in Pixar's library. The emotions feel so real in this film, the opening ten minutes are so powerful yet there isn't a single word of dialogue, it's all told through the excellent score and the magic that is silent cinema. Also, once the main plot gets going, there are tons of great jokes and the adventure is really exciting. That and Up has the most vague title of any film ever and the film is, once again, absolutely unique. This is really a brilliant film, for many reasons.
Rating: 10/10
3. Toy Story 3 (2010)
Oh no, I'm now actually going to start crying! See what I said about Toy Story 2, and apply it to this. It is rare for the third film in a franchise to be this great, let alone the best in the series. The only other franchises I can think of where the third one is the best are some of the Marvel franchises such as Thor or Avengers. This film has all the characters we know and love at their best, a really enjoyable prison escape segment, and even some moments where it feels as if all is lost. I am going to get into spoilers because this film has been out for almost a decade, but that scene with the incinerator is horrifying. I remember sitting in the cinema as a child, convinced I was about to watch some of my heroes be burned to ash. Looking back, obviously they'd never do that, but they made me believe they could for a moment. Above all else, this film beautifully ties up all loose ends, explores themes introduced in previous entries, and perhaps has the most fitting and satisfying conclusion to any animated series and these characters' stories. It was a pleasure to watch them all grow and learn, and it was even nicer to see them finish their story. Oh, wait a minute, it will be nice to see them finish their stories...
Rating: 10/10
2. Cars (2006)
Cars doesn't get a great deal of love and respect from Pixar and animation fans. It is seen as the black sheep of Pixar, probably because of the fact that it got an entire trilogy which featured one film that was rubbish, to others that is. However, I have many personal reasons that make me like Cars even more. It was, from what I remember, the first film I saw in the cinema. I remember getting all the toys and watching the film over and over. I also remember watching it at oddly memorable parts of my life (no specifics because it won't connote anything to you). Cars is a film that means a lot to me, and it is such a great film in addition. The opening scene never fails to get my blood pumping and put a huge grin on my face, the characters always raise a smile and deliver a chuckle, and the message is familiar but so well presented. I know you may disagree, but nothing can change my view on this film. I could never dislike Cars, even if somebody took apart the entire film and raised the most valid points about how flawed it is, I could never look at this film in negative light. There's too much good about it.
I'd also like to address all the nitwits who point out inconsistencies in the world of Cars, such as "How could Doc Hudson frame that newspaper and hang it on the wall when he is a car?" That is a very good point, but what's important is what is in the frame, not how it was put on the wall. There's no need to be so pedantic because that has nothing to do with the overall ride of the film, unless you need to know every little aspect of how the world functions, which you don't.
Rating: 10/10
1. Finding Nemo (2003)
The main reason why Finding Nemo tops my list, aside from the touching story, endearing characters and astounding animation, is because I know that I can watch it whenever, and not be bored or in any way distasteful. There is not a single flaw I can identify here. This is the only film that has ever been made where I am certain I will always love it, regardless of how I'm feeling or what mood I'm in. It's such a well executed adventure and has so many memorable and even iconic encounters with sea life. Even the animation, which will soon enough be 20 years old, still holds up remarkably. I absolutely adore this film, and on some occasions, I have claimed it to be my favourite film of all time. It is that good.
Rating: 10/10
Conclusion
Well, that's all of them. When I look back on this company's filmography, I realise just how many of these films were crucial to my childhood. Many of these were my main source of entertainment for ages. These films defined my childhood and while I will admit they are slowly running out of steam, I am always keen to see what they will deliver next. I hope these films continue to entertain, engage and inspire all children of the present and future, because they are some of the greatest achievements in not just modern animation, but modern cinema. Right, onto Toy Story 4...